Let's talk Knives; The overdue thread.

xyoverland

[fully disclosed]
Supporting Member
Location
Virginia
Correction. The ones given to us 12 years ago are Henckles. They worked for 12 years. Not a huge fan.
Which ones? Henckle has many “classes” of knives. I had an amazing set that if I remember correctly were German made, then told somebody about them for a wedding present idea, and we got Henckle “Statement” which are made in China and very noticeably lower quality.
 

Fromfrontier2Xterra

I bought a Taco
Super Moderator
Supporting Member
Location
All over PA
Which ones? Henckle has many “classes” of knives. I had an amazing set that if I remember correctly were German made, then told somebody about them for a wedding present idea, and we got Henckle “Statement” which are made in China and very noticeably lower quality.
Mine was a wedding gift too. I have a feeling they are probably made in China. Will have to check.
 

TerryD

Total Tease
Supporting Member
Location
Covington, Va
I’m probably not skilled enough to use stones on something small like a knife, but I see Lanksy makes sharpeners with 17° angles. Would you recommend that route for quick touch ups? I’m not too hard on my blades (I have cheapies for those situations) so I just need general maintenance.
Maybe? I don't really know.

What I usually suggest, is buy an inexpensive Smith's Arkansas stone from Walmart and start learning.

Mark your edge with a sharpie and work on your angle until you remove the entire sharpie from the edge cleanly.

Even numbers of strokes on each side to keep the edge centered.

Spend a few minutes each evening practicing while you watch TV.

Also look into buying or making a simple strop. Mine is some tanned leather a buddy gave me glued to a piece of 3/4" plywood. I have the cheap black and green honing compound on it.

It's a skill and once you develop it, if you need to touch up your edge on the fly you can. On the milder materials like your carbon steels and even S30V, you can touch the edge up on the edge of a car window and strop it on the back of your belt and be ready to go again if you need to.

I'm not the best out there. But I can put a usable edge back on my blades or axe if I need to. And like I said, I have the Lansky to fix anything I mess up or if the blade gets chipped.
 

TerryD

Total Tease
Supporting Member
Location
Covington, Va
I know this isn't the typical knife question as we always talk about multi-tools, pocket knives, etc.

However, I need a new set of good kitchen knives. I checked out my usual go to's of spyderco and benchmade but they only have one-off's. Butcher knife, filet, etc. i want a good set. Suggestions?
Victorinox actually makes some pretty nice and reasonably affordable chef's knives. And for butcher knives, look into Old Hickory by OKC. They're a classic and for good reason.
 

Fromfrontier2Xterra

I bought a Taco
Super Moderator
Supporting Member
Location
All over PA
Which ones? Henckle has many “classes” of knives. I had an amazing set that if I remember correctly were German made, then told somebody about them for a wedding present idea, and we got Henckle “Statement” which are made in China and very noticeably lower quality.
Checked. They're made in China. Will look at the sets made in Germany.
 

xyoverland

[fully disclosed]
Supporting Member
Location
Virginia
Maybe? I don't really know.

What I usually suggest, is buy an inexpensive Smith's Arkansas stone from Walmart and start learning.

Mark your edge with a sharpie and work on your angle until you remove the entire sharpie from the edge cleanly.

Even numbers of strokes on each side to keep the edge centered.

Spend a few minutes each evening practicing while you watch TV.

Also look into buying or making a simple strop. Mine is some tanned leather a buddy gave me glued to a piece of 3/4" plywood. I have the cheap black and green honing compound on it.

It's a skill and once you develop it, if you need to touch up your edge on the fly you can. On the milder materials like your carbon steels and even S30V, you can touch the edge up on the edge of a car window and strop it on the back of your belt and be ready to go again if you need to.

I'm not the best out there. But I can put a usable edge back on my blades or axe if I need to. And like I said, I have the Lansky to fix anything I mess up or if the blade gets chipped.
I just watched a video on the 5-stone, and I see it includes a clamp and guides to keep the angle. I thought they were just stones where I had to do it all manually. Since it's guided I may go that route.
 

TerryD

Total Tease
Supporting Member
Location
Covington, Va
I just watched a video on the 5-stone, and I see it includes a clamp and guides to keep the angle. I thought they were just stones where I had to do it all manually. Since it's guided I may go that route.
That's why I use it for repairs and such. I actually have the standard 5 stone and the diamond 4 stone set for some of the more exotic steels I've encountered.

Whoever had my CR2.5 had convexed the edge till it had so many angle changes I couldn't get it right by hand. 15min on my Lansky and it is a scalpel.
 

xyoverland

[fully disclosed]
Supporting Member
Location
Virginia
That's why I use it for repairs and such. I actually have the standard 5 stone and the diamond 4 stone set for some of the more exotic steels I've encountered.

Whoever had my CR2.5 had convexed the edge till it had so many angle changes I couldn't get it right by hand. 15min on my Lansky and it is a scalpel.
Ordered. And already decided I’m going to sell the Bugout I got a few hours ago. Maybe it’s because my 940 is still new and I really like that, but the new one doesn’t really do it for me. I may switch to a Bugout Mini and keep that as a pass-down to my son for camping trips.
 

Xterrorista

Charcoal Briquette
Supporting Member
Location
Denton, TX
Ordered. And already decided I’m going to sell the Bugout I got a few hours ago. Maybe it’s because my 940 is still new and I really like that, but the new one doesn’t really do it for me. I may switch to a Bugout Mini and keep that as a pass-down to my son for camping trips.
Ooh, was just looking at the BO mini, cool lil knife.
 

TheCrabby1

I Smell Fishy
Supporting Member
Location
Burtonsville, Md
I know this isn't the typical knife question as we always talk about multi-tools, pocket knives, etc.

However, I need a new set of good kitchen knives. I checked out my usual go to's of spyderco and benchmade but they only have one-off's. Butcher knife, filet, etc. i want a good set. Suggestions?
Henckels and Wusthof are great cutlery from Solingen , Germany . $$ ; But you get what you pay for !
 

TerryD

Total Tease
Supporting Member
Location
Covington, Va
So another forum I'm on has a knife pass around for one of the makers on the site. It was my turn with it and yesterday afforded me some time to play with it a little.

20220306_103424.jpg


Just shy of 5" of edge, 5 3/8" to the scales and 10" over all length with a 3/16" spine and hollow grind make it an interesting sized knife.

The scales are beautiful. Just no arguing that. The finish on the blade is pretty rough. You can still feel the grinder marks in it. But it's a pass around, abuser knife to test the makers skill and it still looks awesome.

I batoned a little, chopped a little and made some feather sticks.

20220305_142017.jpg


20220305_142258.jpg

The size and balance of the knife made it very nice for batoning and feather sticks.

The handle is a little short and the lack of a good pommel swell made it a little hard to hang on to when chopping. It was doable, but I had to keep adjusting my grip, especially in the gloves I was wearing.

20220305_142452.jpg

Overall, I like the knife a lot. I'm gonna carry it around for a bit and play with it some more before I pass it along to the next guy....
 

Xterrorista

Charcoal Briquette
Supporting Member
Location
Denton, TX
So another forum I'm on has a knife pass around for one of the makers on the site. It was my turn with it and yesterday afforded me some time to play with it a little.

View attachment 22293


Just shy of 5" of edge, 5 3/8" to the scales and 10" over all length with a 3/16" spine and hollow grind make it an interesting sized knife.

The scales are beautiful. Just no arguing that. The finish on the blade is pretty rough. You can still feel the grinder marks in it. But it's a pass around, abuser knife to test the makers skill and it still looks awesome.

I batoned a little, chopped a little and made some feather sticks.

View attachment 22294


View attachment 22295

The size and balance of the knife made it very nice for batoning and feather sticks.

The handle is a little short and the lack of a good pommel swell made it a little hard to hang on to when chopping. It was doable, but I had to keep adjusting my grip, especially in the gloves I was wearing.

View attachment 22296

Overall, I like the knife a lot. I'm gonna carry it around for a bit and play with it some more before I pass it along to the next guy....
Pretty ku
 

TerryD

Total Tease
Supporting Member
Location
Covington, Va
I had visions of J. Neilson when I read this. Nice looking knife. Just got my forge haven't even got it together yet. So no experience of my own. Hoping to be able to that well at some point.
That's probably how I looked bashing at that green piece of oak yesterday, trying to chop it.
 

TheCrabby1

I Smell Fishy
Supporting Member
Location
Burtonsville, Md
Although I'm not the Knife aficionado last weekend I lost my Buck Commander fold . I've been so happy with it that I went and ordered it's replacement on Mon. Then on Thur I found it under Quark's driver's seat [ yes I named the 2011 P4x after another DS9 character ] Anyway now I have twin's with the exception that the new one is slightly bigger .20220320_072733.jpg
 

jsexton

Need Bigger Tires
Location
Lewis Center, OH
I know this isn't the typical knife question as we always talk about multi-tools, pocket knives, etc.

However, I need a new set of good kitchen knives. I checked out my usual go to's of spyderco and benchmade but they only have one-off's. Butcher knife, filet, etc. i want a good set. Suggestions?

Wusthof classic icon. worth every penny.

We have a full set. I use the 6" chefs knife so much that we bought a 2nd.

 

maillet282

If you bleeding, Imma fix you
Moderator
Location
Ontario Canada
found Put a couple days ago that my best friend where I currently live since we were deployed in Ukraine back in 2017 is getting posted away. Ended up ordering him a Keyshawn Blur with partially serrated blade and window punch. Along with a deep pocket titanium pocket clip today. Hope I can get everything in hand and put together ( longest part will be waiting for the MXG clip) before he leaves at the beginning of July
 

Bklyn.X

Skid Plates
Moderator
Supporting Member
Founding Member
Location
Brooklyn, NY
This is my Leatherman Skeletool:

214641DF-D649-44AB-A7D6-0D3015F293E4.jpeg


I got it years ago for work, opening boxes, cutting rope, cutting plastic, occasional screwdriver or pliers when the need arises and I'm too lazy to fetch the "real tool".
Even though I liked that it was very easy to deploy the blade I found it too bulky to carry daily in my front pocket and with the amount of use I gave it the clip started wearing the pocket of my jeans.
The sheath it came with slowed the one hand quick deploy blade I got the tool for. I stopped carrying it.

About a year ago I saw this:

F38082B8-BBDF-48FE-9692-25A3CA750F2C.jpeg

Clip & Carry Kydex Sheath Belt Clip Holster Holder on amazon and thought I'd give it a try. It brought the tool back to life and It is now the most used tool I own. It doesn't fall out of the clip even riding a bike to and from work but comes out easy one hand motion, deploys in a second. It's on my belt every work day and put to use many times during those days.

Money well spent

I recommend
 

Xterrorista

Charcoal Briquette
Supporting Member
Location
Denton, TX
This is my Leatherman Skeletool:

214641DF-D649-44AB-A7D6-0D3015F293E4.jpeg


I got it years ago for work, opening boxes, cutting rope, cutting plastic, occasional screwdriver or pliers when the need arises and I'm too lazy to fetch the "real tool".
Even though I liked that it was very easy to deploy the blade I found it too bulky to carry daily in my front pocket and with the amount of use I gave it the clip started wearing the pocket of my jeans.
The sheath it came with slowed the one hand quick deploy blade I got the tool for. I stopped carrying it.

About a year ago I saw this:

F38082B8-BBDF-48FE-9692-25A3CA750F2C.jpeg

Clip & Carry Kydex Sheath Belt Clip Holster Holder on amazon and thought I'd give it a try. It brought the tool back to life and It is now the most used tool I own. It doesn't fall out of the clip even riding a bike to and from work but comes out easy one hand motion, deploys in a second. It's on my belt every work day and put to use many times during those days.

Money well spent

I recommend
Now that's cool. I've worn out two factory nylon sheaths carrying my Gerber multi tool and stopped using it daily far that reason. Is it mfg specific?
 

maillet282

If you bleeding, Imma fix you
Moderator
Location
Ontario Canada
Now that's cool. I've worn out two factory nylon sheaths carrying my Gerber multi tool and stopped using it daily far that reason. Is it mfg specific?
with any kydex or molded sheath it will be knide/ multi tool specific. You can look up what model gerber you have then look ip for kydex sheath and should be able to find something that suites your needs
 

maillet282

If you bleeding, Imma fix you
Moderator
Location
Ontario Canada
This is my Leatherman Skeletool:

214641DF-D649-44AB-A7D6-0D3015F293E4.jpeg


I got it years ago for work, opening boxes, cutting rope, cutting plastic, occasional screwdriver or pliers when the need arises and I'm too lazy to fetch the "real tool".
Even though I liked that it was very easy to deploy the blade I found it too bulky to carry daily in my front pocket and with the amount of use I gave it the clip started wearing the pocket of my jeans.
The sheath it came with slowed the one hand quick deploy blade I got the tool for. I stopped carrying it.

About a year ago I saw this:

F38082B8-BBDF-48FE-9692-25A3CA750F2C.jpeg

Clip & Carry Kydex Sheath Belt Clip Holster Holder on amazon and thought I'd give it a try. It brought the tool back to life and It is now the most used tool I own. It doesn't fall out of the clip even riding a bike to and from work but comes out easy one hand motion, deploys in a second. It's on my belt every work day and put to use many times during those days.

Money well spent

I recommend
I’ve been looking at theirCanadian Amazon store for something for mu Leatherman raptor shears
 
Top