Work boots!

KChurch86

Banned
Founding Member
Alright guys and gals, I need your input. I'm on my feet at work for 45-65 hours a week, and I'm pretty over-due for a new pair of work boots. My current pair have held up very well, and are still going strong; other than the holes worn through them by the balls of my feet.

I want to buy my next pair online, because the local boot shops here are very over-priced. I'd like to get the same exact boots I have now, in the same size, because:

A) They fit great
B) They're the most comfortable boots I've owned
C) They're affordable
D) They've held up to about 5 1/2 years of constant abuse, and other than the soles wearing through, they're still in very good condition.

My current boots are Timberland Pro Series, mid-top I guess you'd call them. They're not low-tops, and not high-tops. I've never been a fan of low-top work boots, they don't offer enough ankle support for me. I just have no need for high-tops.

I'm open to other brands and styles as well. I don't want to spend a boat load of cash on them, which is silly when it comes to work boots; I know. Unless I can get a killer deal of course. I've tried the whole work-sneaker thing, and only found one pair that I liked. I don't remember the model, but they were made by Stanley. I'd like to keep it simple with a good, honest, work boot.

To meet safety requirements, the boots must be steel toe, and oil-resistance is a plus. I'd really like mid-tops, but would consider high-tops as well.

The biggest problem is that I've got extremely flat feet, so bad that my feet roll inwards towards where my arches should be. This throws everything in my legs out of alignment, and has caused me to wear out the cartilage in my knees. When I was 14, and unable to walk up/down stairs or squat without excruciating pain, I was told by specialists that by 16 I'd need to have both knees replaced. I'm 27 now, and still on my original knees, though they are in terrible shape. We've been planning on a double knee replacement in the near future. The misalignment is also making it's way upwards to my back, which has recently started giving me more trouble than before.

I had custom orthodic inserts made to strengthen and re-shape my feet, and I went through a month of physical therapy to strengthen the tendons and ligaments to help form the arch; but never saw any progress from it. The orthodic inserts are very expensive and insurance won't cover it. Last time I had them made I spent just shy of $500 on a pair, and they didn't last all that long. I've found some decent Dr. Scholl's inserts that seem to work well for me, so I'll likely be pairing these with whatever boots I choose.


And so, I ask you, good people of XterraNation, to voice your opinions on work boots! If you could use the following form, that'd be killer... :)

Brand & model :
Price range (approximate or guess is fine) :
Steel toe :
Oil/slip resistant :
Specialty comfort features :
Sizing (How close to a 12, for example, is a 12? i.e. Do they run big or small?) :
Personal experience with brand/model :
Link to a deal? :


This is my Dr. Scholl's insert, the original boot insole, and the upper sole of the boot. These are from the left boot, and between the two boots, this is the smaller of the two holes. I didn't want to pull everything out of the right boot for fear that it would tear and not be usable any longer. The hole in the right boot continues right on through to the top side of the sole.

Insoles_zpsf2f19e4f.jpg


See? Still lots of life left on the outside. They'll definitely be retired to spares/yard work boots:

Boots_zpsb3384fc5.jpg
 
Last edited:

J Everett

Suspension Lift
Founding Member
Location
Houma, LA
I also have kind of flat arches and the resulting knee pain.
Since you said you were open to other brands, I have to recommend the Wolverine CarbonMax boots I've been using for close to 7 years now. The toe is a carbon fiber cup instead of steel, but it meets all of the same safety ratings that steel toes have to conform to. But it is much lighter and more comfortable. I swear, you could jog in these things. They've held up really well too. Cost me $100 at my local Academy sporting goods store. It's possible that Amazon or Zappos would carry them as well.

My boots (they're only worn 4 or 5 days every other week, so they don't look like 7 year old boots):
2889D1CD-044F-43DA-A632-02E243B8D072-13163-0000199192B48697_zpsb59cbff3.jpg




Even if you're not sure about the carbon toe cap, Wolverines have proven to be the most comfortable steel toe boots I've found. Give em a shot.



Amazon has them: http://www.amazon.com/Wolverine-Mens-Guardian-W02292-Waterproof/dp/B004U8O6IU/ref=pd_sbs_shoe_1
 
Last edited:

metzican

Suspension Lift
Location
Lafaytte, la
I can't recommend work boots because I always go through them to fast due to becoming soaked with nasty chemicals and only a few carry my size. Timberland I have found the most comfortable. Red wings and wolverines hold up great. I usually blow the sides out of my timberland in about 6 mounts or if they don't do that I ware a hole through the bottom if the chemical don't melt the souls before then. I ware steel toes 13hours a day for 14 days straight then they get 14 days rest.
 

KChurch86

Banned
Founding Member
I can't speak to this because I'm not on my feet enough for the comfort of my boot to come into play. Good luck church.

Haha, well thanks anyway Mac!

I also have kind of flat arches and the resulting knee pain.
Since you said you were open to other brands, I have to recommend the Wolverine CarbonMax boots I've been using for close to 7 years now. The toe is a carbon fiber cup instead of steel, but it meets all of the same safety ratings that steel toes have to conform to. But it is much lighter and more comfortable. I swear, you could jog in these things. They've held up really well too. Cost me $100 at my local Academy sporting goods store. It's possible that Amazon or Zappos would carry them as well.

My boots (they're only worn 4 or 5 days every other week, so they don't look like 7 year old boots):
2889D1CD-044F-43DA-A632-02E243B8D072-13163-0000199192B48697_zpsb59cbff3.jpg




Even if you're not sure about the carbon toe cap, Wolverines have proven to be the most comfortable steel toe boots I've found. Give em a shot.



Amazon has them: http://www.amazon.com/Wolverine-Mens-Guardian-W02292-Waterproof/dp/B004U8O6IU/ref=pd_sbs_shoe_1

Thanks for the recommendation J. I don't really think weight is a concern of mine, but I've also only ever worn steel toes, so I've just gotten used to the weight. These might be a nice change for me, I'll keep them in mind!

I can't recommend work boots because I always go through them to fast due to becoming soaked with nasty chemicals and only a few carry my size. Timberland I have found the most comfortable. Red wings and wolverines hold up great. I usually blow the sides out of my timberland in about 6 mounts or if they don't do that I ware a hole through the bottom if the chemical don't melt the souls before then. I ware steel toes 13hours a day for 14 days straight then they get 14 days rest.

What kind of work do you do/chemicals do you come in contact with? My boots will be subjected to various chemicals as well, but nothing that will seriously damage them.
 

metzican

Suspension Lift
Location
Lafaytte, la
What kind of work do you do/chemicals do you come in contact with? My boots will be subjected to various chemicals as well, but nothing that will seriously damage them.

I work on a drilling rig so a lot of oils/Diesal, salts, crazy cleaning soaps, Caustic soda, Soda ash. The worst is high weight brines they can shrink a leather boot to half its size in a day.
 

J Everett

Suspension Lift
Founding Member
Location
Houma, LA
I forgot to add, even if you buy online, find whatever you intend to buy somewhere local and try them on before you buy them. I buy a lot of shoes online, and only once out of ten purchases or so did I get the right size on the first try and didn't have to send them back for another size. That includes a pair of Timberland boots. Shoe sizes are supposed to be universal, but they just aren't.
 

ThePlasticOne

First Fill-Up (of many)
Location
Boston, MA
I have worn the same pair of Michelin XHY866 Hydroedge boots for the last six years and they show no signs of slowing down.

yhst-17665666401044_2256_187364695


Mine:
photo393m.jpg


photo394.jpg


photo395c.jpg



Low range about $125, average $150, also available in brown. Slip and oil resistant, as well as electrically insulated, waterproof, and puncture-resistant, mid-top. I've shuffled through five New England winters with these (2011 was a bust) and all six years were spent in welding shops. As you can see I've also started to wear the heels down but I haven't noticed it at all. They might never die. The nice thing is that they come in wide sizes, which is great for me. They're not true steel caps (composite) but they are amazingly comfortable. Tread is practically perfect still. They breathe great. The only reason I get uncomfortable in them is because I've been standing all day. Plus, a teeny Michelin Man is embossed on the side.
 

KChurch86

Banned
Founding Member
I have worn the same pair of Michelin XHY866 Hydroedge boots for the last six years and they show no signs of slowing down.

yhst-17665666401044_2256_187364695


Mine:
photo393m.jpg


photo394.jpg


photo395c.jpg



Low range about $125, average $150, also available in brown. Slip and oil resistant, as well as electrically insulated, waterproof, and puncture-resistant, mid-top. I've shuffled through five New England winters with these (2011 was a bust) and all six years were spent in welding shops. As you can see I've also started to wear the heels down but I haven't noticed it at all. They might never die. The nice thing is that they come in wide sizes, which is great for me. They're not true steel caps (composite) but they are amazingly comfortable. Tread is practically perfect still. They breathe great. The only reason I get uncomfortable in them is because I've been standing all day. Plus, a teeny Michelin Man is embossed on the side.

So, do you mean the imprinted Michelin man is part of the reason you get uncomfortable wearing them? ;)

Thanks for the input! I'll do add them to the list to find in person and compare (thanks for that suggestion, J Everett)).
 

Cyclemut

Wheeling
Founding Member
Location
Morrison, CO
I've worn Red Wings now for almost 20 years. I'm on the 7th year of my current pair, had them resoled once and they're due to be retired now. I also walk a little funny so I've worn the soles down oddly.

8" full uppers, full steel toe, steel shank, oil and slip resistant, full leather. Around $280 or so for the full uppers, so mid uppers would be cheaper. I also tend to kick the legs of my lift under the vehicles when I'm racking them, so I've worn the leather off the top of the toe down to the steel on every pair. But you can get an epoxy that goes over them to prevent that from happening. I think it's mostly a mechanic thing though.

But I'm currently looking at Snap-On boots, for around $160. Supposed to be really comfortable, from what a couple of the guys are telling me.

 
Top