So... After all that. I actually decided to keep them. I really can't explain why either. To answer, yes I liked the Duratracs on road. I like them better on road than the X3's for sure. The X3's are already about as noisy as the Duratracs were when they were nearly worn out. The off road part, well, the X3's are pretty damn great. I haven't noticed much in the way of MPG loss, maybe a tad.
I just needed a change, and after having driven 1000 miles towing the trailer, 300 or so miles off road, and crawling, and another 700 plus miles regular, I've gotten used to them.
It could be that my Duratracs were so worn, that anything with a full tread would have felt wobbly, I just don't know.
All that being said, will I buy 'em again? ... probably not.... would I buy the Duratracs again, absolutely.
P.s. thanks for posting in here
@General_Tarfun, and
@Me!Here! , it reminded me to actually post up about this..... and eat some crow.